Sheet Reviews

This item can't be beat for cooking with BUT if you have an overzealous husband who washes everything in the dishwasher you will end up with a warped sheet that won't come clean.

Now my mother has had the same one for at least 5-6 years, she has never washed it with dishwashing detergent, but simply wipes it off with a damp paper towel after using it and it comes right clean.

I really love this set. The pizza pan is wonderful!! I always had problems with the way pizza tasted when baked in the oven because the bottom was either burnt or mushy. Not anymore!! It's perfect pizza from now on. Oh, and the cookie sheets are nice, too.

I've been buying airware cookie sheets and such for awhile now. I swear they are the best sheets I've ever used. They look nice, they don't burn food as easy as regular cookies sheets, easy to clean and stay 'like new' for years with proper care and washing.

Prior to my purchase of this cookie sheet I was totally devoted to All-Clad cookware. But, this cookie sheet was a real wake-up call!
The first time it was used it buckled. Ever try to bake gingerbread men on a buckled sheet?
Further, the bottoms were black before the cookie was done. The first time, my assumption was that I had somehow erred although we have used this same recipe for a number of years. No, I didn't err - the same unhappy results with the second batch.
Frustrated, I pulled out an old inexpensive cookie sheet and the results were perfect.
I had thought All-Clad was perfect - it isn't.

I have used this cookie sheet for over two years. It is the best I have used. I bake homemade cookies about once a week, so this sheet has been used a lot. I went over to someone's house who had an airbake pan, the cookies took longer to bake with the airbake and those pans wear out way too fast. This pan is worth the investment. You'll never have to buy another cookie sheet.

If you buy this cookie sheet, you won't regret it. The sheet maintains an even temperature, allowing all your cookies to bake to that perfect golden brown. It works well with and without parchment paper. This cookie sheet is well worth the price.

The past few batches of cookies I've made on these pans just didn't turn out well at all. There's definitely no problem with burning, but they just don't cook the cookies right - they'll be nice and brown all over, but when I take them out, they just flatten into a very ugly cookie, like the insides aren't cooked well or something. And my cookies stick, even when the recipe says to use an ungreased pan. I'm going to look into a different kind of pan.

I bought 2 for my Christmas cookies in December, and they worked beautifully. No burnt cookies, just golden brown perfection. I didn't have to try to adjust recipes for the darker coating on a nonstick sheet, and I could use my metal spatula. If I ever need more cookie sheets, I'll buy these again.

Cookies, tea rings, breads, tarts, cream puffs, you name it, it never burns or blackens as can happen with other bakeware. In decades of minor catering use, this is the best I've ever seen.

I ordered two of these cookie sheets.
They shipped them seperately!! Charging me 6 dollars each cookie sheet. Costing me 20 dollars when all was said and done for only one cookie sheet. Both cookie sheets ended up costing me FOURTY DOLLARS!!!!!!!!!! SO DON"T BUY THEM HERE!!!
You can get them At Walmart for only nine dollars!!!
What a RIP OFF!!!

Sure, the shipping cost might be a little more than the typical person wants to pay. Let me assure you that it is worth it! No more dark brown bottoms on your cookies--who can put a price on that? I bought my first one at a different retailer here in town, then wanted another one because my other cookie sheet just didn't compare. (All cookie makers know that it is so much easier to bake cookies when you have 2 sheets going in rotation) Anyway, so I went back to said shop--only to find they didn't carry them anymore! The nearest Target is over an hour away, so I'd just rather pay the shipping than gas. I hope this review has helped qualm any doubts you have about ordering this fabulous cookie sheet. It is a must have for anyone who wants the best tasting cookies. My engineering husband can't get over the fact that a woman came up with this idea--it was such a smart move, yet a simple concept. Makes all the difference!
p.s. (He was the one that insisted I buy another Airbake--in his words,'why ruin half of the batch anymore?')

Wow! This is literally one amazing cookie sheet. I never have to grease this pan or have to worry about anything sticking. I cook EVERYTHING in the oven on this pan and I have a few of them. This is a lifetime investment. You won't be sorry!